Last Night’s TV – Cutting Edge: Madeleine Was Here

This was a very emotive film, as of course all media reports about missing children are and especially this high profile case, but the McCann’s have had to face so much, I wonder how they’re still standing; how they’re still functioning and able to live with what any parent will know must be the horrific thoughts about what could have happened to their daughter.
I can think of few things worse than having your child abducted, except perhaps not knowing what happened to her and if she’s dead or alive.
As we all know, on May 3rd 2007, their daughter Madeleine was abducted from their holiday apartment in the Portugese resort of Praia da Luz and she’s never been seen again. This Cutting Edge documentary examined the circumstances of her disappearance as well as catching up with how Kate and Gerry McCann have been coping with everything that’s happened to them since that fateful and devastating night…
They were of course suspects themselves for a while and vilified for leaving their children unattended in an apartment which is, as Gerry talked about in the film, something they have to live with on their consciences on a daily basis. The ‘what ifs’ must plague them night and day.
However, I was very surprised to hear Gerry say in the film that “No law agency is proactively doing anything” to find their daughter, which is why they’ve employed two former British police detectives – Dave Edgar and Arthur Cowley – to search for Madeleine using funds raised by their Find Madeleine appeal.
We were also told that the Portuguese police have now “shelved” their investigation into Madeleine’s disappearance and have released some 30,000 documents to Kate and Gerry McCann which detail their investigation. Kate, who now stays at home to look after their two other children, Sean and Amelie, goes over these documents relentlessly, hoping to spot something, some clue, that’s been overlooked. And quite apart from that, who can blame her for not wanting to take her eyes off her two other children whenever possible?
During last night’s film, we saw Gerry McCann returning for the first time since they originally left the resort to Apartment 5a of the Ocean Club complex, which is where the family were staying and where he last saw his daughter.

Also returning to Portugal to take part in a reconstruction of the events of that night were Jane Tanner and Matthew Oldfield, two friends from the group known as the ‘Tapas 7′, who were on holiday with the McCanns’ at the time.
The documentary reconstructed that critical night using eye witness testimony and where possible, the actual people involved such as Jane, who believes she actually saw Madeleine being carried away, but at the time, didn’t immediately assume she was witnessing an abduction; a fact that she finds hard to deal with now because she of course realises that her intervention at that moment could’ve meant that Madeleine was at this minute safe at home with her family. That must be a terrible burden for her to bear and it was heart rending to see her weep as she watched the actor playing Madeleine’s abductor carrying a child…

We heard how the two investigators, Dave and Arthur, are working on the theory that a man who was seen by several witnesses hanging around and staring at the McCann’s apartment is the man who took Madeleine, but of course, his purposes for doing so aren’t known. This is the latest artist’s impression of that man…

Dave and Arthur are optimistic regarding Madeleine’s fate in that her body has never been found, so one of their many working theories is that Madeleine was taken to subsequently be ‘adopted’…
I hope that’s the case; I really hope that one day, whenever that may be, that a girl comes along and says, “I think I’m Madeleine McCann”, but as far as I could see, the biggest flaw in this theory is that surely if a child were to be abducted for that reason, the ‘adopter’ would want a baby? And there were two babies in that room along with Madeleine but they were not taken.
Later in the film, I was horrified to see and hear that the locals and residents of Praia da Luz are so angry that this case has caused a reduction of holidaymakers to the area – and therefore affected their livelihoods – that they not only heckled Gerry McCann but had covered a billboard that showed Madeleine’s picture with paint. Have these people no compassion?? Gerry and Kate McCann were far more forgiving of this hostility than I would be, saying that they understood that the locals just “want it to go away”, but would the residents of Praia da Luz feel the same if it was one of their children who was missing?
It was and is repugnant that they’ve behaved in this way, and while I wouldn’t have boycotted the resort because Madeleine went missing there, I would now, simply because people who can be so callous and self-interested don’t deserve my or anyone else’s holiday custom in my opinion.
The entire programme was hard to watch; from seeing Kate and Gerry McCann with a certain something ‘missing’ from their eyes and faces – while trying to keep a façade of normality for their other children – to seeing how Gerry, Jane and Matthew Oldfield clearly reopened barely healed wounds by revisiting the area for the purposes of the reconstruction. It was clear that everyone involved that night – the so called Tapas 7 – feels a weight of responsibility which must feel like drowning in a sea of regret, sorrow and if-onlys.
It was also intensely moving too to see Kate and Gerry visiting the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children in the United States where they spent weeks helping the artists and computer technicians there build a picture of what Madeleine – at six – may look like now. These are the images that the center produced…


It was so sad to see Kate fighting back tears as she looked at a picture of a child she didn’t know, yet this child is very probably what her daughter looks like now. And it was distressing to think that it’s very possible that if Madeleine is alive, she may not have any idea of who she really is and may not even remember her ‘before’ family…
Kate said, “I only remember Madeleine when she was four. She remains four years old in my mind” but their fervent hope is that these new images will be seen by someone who recognises the child Madeleine will now be, and I so hope it works.
While in America, Kate and Gerry appeared on the Oprah Winfrey show to discuss the new age progression images and as always, their raw pain was clear to see and painful to watch… Here’s some of the footage from that interview.
Dave Edgar and Arthur Cowley remain convinced that the abductor is/was a local man and that someone in the resort knows who he is and what happened to Madeleine; they just need one person to come forward. As Dave explained in the film, “There’s someone local, lives locally, has the answer to this, and not much wider than 10 or 15 kilometres away from Praia de Luz.”
Arthur agrees and added, “The answer still lies in Praia de Luz, and it’s important that we focus on Praia de Luz and the surrounding area.”
Now the investigators hope that last night’s documentary and reconstruction may jog the memories of others who may know, or have seen, something significant. You can see the latest information about the case at www.findmadeleine.com
Overall, my personal feelings have been altered since this all first hit the headlines. My first thoughts were, how could intelligent, responsible people just leave their small children unattended in apartments like that? And I also believed that if the parents of Madeleine had been people from a ‘lower’ social class who’d done the same thing, there was a very real possibility that their remaining children would’ve been taken from them and placed in local authority care.
However, my feelings have changed over the last two years in that when I see the pain etched into the faces of the McCann’s, I can’t help but feel anything but sympathy and empathy for them. Yes of course it was horribly irresponsible to leave their children unattended, but not only have they paid the worst price imaginable for that decision, they will surely have punished themselves for that fact more than most of us can possibly imagine or make worse by continuing to berate them for that huge mistake.
The not knowing must be killing them but at the same time, keeping them going, because of course, Madeleine may be out there somewhere still, living under a different name in a new life and one day, she may come back to them.
The alternative is that she isn’t, and again, one day, her remains may be discovered and the McCann’s will at least then know, but I sincerely pray that it’s the former scenario that turns out to be the case.
This moving but important documentary did what it intended to do; it kept Madeleine in the public eye and therefore didn’t allow us to forget about her given that it’s been two years since she went missing. However, one of the many sad things about this case it is that there are thousands more just like it, but they don’t have the high profile that Madeleine does…
Not that I’m criticising Kate and Gerry for keeping up this momentum and constantly putting themselves in the frontline – that’s often more like a firing line – in order to keep the memory of their child fresh in people’s minds all over the world. They’re very brave to do so, given the backlash of hatred towards them whenever they raise their heads above the parapet – but thousands of children go missing every year and few of them remain ‘news’ for more than days, and some don’t even make it that far…
There are websites dedicated to finding missing children here in the UK though and you can see these at www.missingkids.co.uk and find more information here, www.npia.police.uk/missingpersons
Let’s hope that Madeleine is found soon and that an end can be put to the McCann’s suffering. Likewise, although it’s perhaps a naively optimistic hope, let’s hope that other missing children are found as a vicarious result of the raised awareness of this horribly traumatic issue that the McCann’s are ensuring stays very much in the public arena.

Chat about this on the Unreality TV Forum »


How on earth can you write such flowery sugar-coated rubbish? I’m sorry, but even the slightest bit of investigation reveals a whole laod of questions about the real involvement of the McCanns and their friends in this whole sorry affair. From the incosistent statments, impossibility of events occurring as they describe, deleted text messages on their mobile phones, dog evidence, lack of evidence of abduction and, let’s face it, simple common sense about how they look & behave means they have a whole lot of questions to answer…
Why don’t you look for the Goncalo Amaral documentary as a real portrayal of events that night…
well that was worth watching i dont think,utter rubbish.
lets see Mr Amarals documentry and see how it should be done.
you have really mislead the public on this.
here is Gonçalo Amaral Documentary http://blip.tv/file/2036418
Are you serious?
Gerry called the other 2 witnesses liars about his position on the route. It was then changed to his version.
The irish mans description was entirely different to Tanners description. 40 mins later. Great planning of an abduction.
1. Break into an apartment, jemmying shutters,which has more traffic coming and going from it allegedly than heathrow.
2. Drug 3 sleeping kids, take the older one who can talk.
3. Clean away all traces of you being there. Put cuddlecat on the shelf. open door 5 inches. Spray cadavine scent in 5 places including mothers trousers which werent there. Hide behind the door while Daddy has a jemmy, oh I mean jimmy.
4. Dont go back out the door, climb jump over 2 cots get on a bed and try and get out the window whilst holding the child. All in 5 mins.
5. Then run around town for 40 mins, getting people to see you.
Then both of you disappear into thin air forever.
but dont forget to break into their car 23 days later to put some cadervine scent in the wheel well and a few dollops of dirty nappies rotting meat and cut hair, and 15 markers of her DNA.
what a waste of time watching that!
Whoever wrote that article got it absolutely right. How anyone could have any doubts about the McCann’s innocence after watching the documentary and the Oprah interview is beyond belief.
” They’re very brave to do so, given the backlash of hatred towards them whenever they raise their heads above the parapet”
This is so true and also another indication of their innocence. A guilty person would never draw this much attention to their crime, they would slink off quietly, hoping it would all die down and eventually be forgotten. Good on the McCann’s for keeping the profile of their daughter, Madeleine high, so that no-one ever forgets that she is still out there somewhere. Just don’t ask Goncalo Amoral for his opinion, he will charge you 80,000 for it.
i think you will find that the latest spotty man WAS checked out
and that the chap was in the clear.READ THE PJ FILES PLEASE
and stop trying to fool the public,which is what this so called program has done
Mercy
I agree,
the McCann’s are keeping a high profile for M
Only it’s Money,not Madeleine!
It was a biased McCann led and scripted piece of drivel.
The so called new suspect has been investigated and named and cleared by the Portuguese police.
Do some research,the files are out for everyone to see.
Well, I’ve read the PJ files (entirely), I’ve read Mr. Amaral’s book “The Truth of the Lie”, I’ve watched Mr. Amaral’s documentary, I’ve watched the Oprah Show with the McCann, I’ve watched the Channel 4 McCann’s “mise-en-scene”, and in my opinion this couple are as guilty as hell.
I do not believe a single word they express, except their sorrow and pain for the death of their little girl. And for that I can feel sympathy – it must be horrendous to be guilty about a daughter’s death.
They are deeply involved into Madeleine’s disappearance and it’s about time they start telling the truth.
Here we go, the members of the biggest hate site in the UK once again converge to spam the comments page of any article that does not condemn the McCann’s. Pitchforkers en masse! The McCann’s not only have to suffer the pain of not knowing the fate of their daughter, they must also suffer the injustice of a hate-filled mob. Add to that the vile actions of the disgraced former policeman who was dismissed from the case and is now swanning around Europe making money from the disappearance of a little girl.
PITCHFORKER ALERT
The vigilantes from the3arguidosdotnet will be spamming you to slag off Madeleine’s parents. They’ve been doing it for almost 2 years.
The SACKED policeman on the case WHO WAS COLLECTING MATERIAL FOR HIS BOOK ABOUT MADELEINE WHILE HE WAS STILL SUPPOSEDLY “INVESTIGATING” THE CASE–who now charges EIGHTY THOUSAND EUROS FOR INTERVIEWS (ask Martin Brunt of Sky News)has ADMITTED that the sealing off of the crime scene was NEVER done.
He is CURRENTLY on trial for allegedly turning a blind eye to the torture of ANOTHER MISSING GIRL’S mother, who he ALSO thinks was kept in a fridge (you seeing the theme here?)
AMORAL IS A DAMNED DISGRACE—he is getting rich off the back of a missing child, through his own incompetence at screwing up the investigation—IDIOT
how can any of you have the right to say the McCanns killed thier beautiful daughter? do you have any solid evidence that they were even involved in her dissapearance let alone that they have murdered her?? do you actually think any parent would do that to thier child, a child which by the way they went thru pain and agony to have (if you dont remember Kate had to go thru IVF)….in my opinion Kate and Gerry McCann are totally innocent, they keep Maddie in such a high profile because then the public will be aware of her if she is seen or so on. if you ask me its the Portuguese police who deserve all the hate, if it wasnt for complete lack of focus and urgency when Maddie went missing, she may be back with her family right now!
Good god people..Take a chill pill.
This article is about a missing child, now, have an opinion
but don’t knock the writer for fu*cks sake
The crime scene… When the parents finally called the police they had already allowed all of their friends to mess it. Either this was an innocent mistake or we’re talking about deliberate crime scene tempering. Taking into consideration that this is about professional and articulated people who shouted “Abduction” from the first moment, I choose the second option.
I don’t know what happened to Madeleine McCann but I do know this. As a parent I would move heaven and earth in an attempt to find my daughter and I didn’t witness the McCann’s doing this is the days following their daughter’s abduction. Also why didn’t Kate McCann answer the police questions and why didn’t she and all of the friends attend a police reconstruction?
could you put something or let persons know madeleine gets called lapetite by the small france circus family a woman a man and two kids who somehow got her from the long haired guy in portugal who stole her and she was with them in amserdam she said her name is maddy and they took her from her mummy on holiday could you let france know and dont forget to add that stuff in people need to know thanks from ladonna